CarlosRuiz: full meeting

2012-02-22T20:20:50Z

full meeting

CarlosRuiz: proposed agenda

2012-02-15T15:34:15Z

proposed agenda

New page

<font size=-2>
⇐
[[IDempiere|Table of Contents]] |
[[IDempiere/Full Meeting Minutes|Full Meeting Minutes]] |
Full Meeting 2012-02-22
</font>

Proposed themes to discuss:
* git vs mercurial (proposed by hengsin)

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:20, 22 February 2012
Line 9:		Line 9:
	Proposed themes to discuss:		Proposed themes to discuss:
	* git vs mercurial (proposed by hengsin)		* git vs mercurial (proposed by hengsin)
		+
		+	----
		+
		+
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': Hello<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': Hola<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': How did the interview of new candidate goes yesterday?<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': went fine - we'll see<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': Doing some cleanup of a very bad migration script (one of those bombs) - but please feel free to ask or discuss anything - we're on idempiere meeting time<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': oh yes ..it is now!<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': hi carlos<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': Hi hengsin <br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': carlos, any reason why we should not just use the wiki provided by bitbucket ?<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': do you want to discuss git vs mercurial?<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': yeah, we can do that now<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': would like to see tbayen joining the discussion - but he seems to be away<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': hengsin, we can use bitbucket wiki - but personally I don't like the formatting of those pages<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': and the syntax is very different than mediawiki<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': yeah, it is different syntax<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': anyway, maybe we can use that first while waiting for something better ?<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': if someone goes ahead and use it…<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': or we could think on a free hosting like wikkii - but I think there is one directly from mediawiki foundation<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': ok, lets look around and we can discuss again this next week.<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': another option is to ask for sponsorship of an AWS server - and I'll try to get somebody to set it up<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': joel.s have say he can but no definite answer from him yet<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': ever thought of SourceForge.net improved free resources?<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': I don't have experience with git - trying to read some vs. docs here<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': interesting there is an hg client for git servers http://hg-git.github.com/<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': yeah, that's the tool people use to migrate from hg to git<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': the 3 positive that I'm aware of 1) git is officially support by eclipse.org 2) buckminster support 3) Gerrit<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': #3 is not of use though if we dont have a sponsor server for it.<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': maybe we should put this aside first until we have better picture of the infra ?<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': hengsin, I would be fine with git if you prefer it - as I see it's basically same as mercurial - just change of command line syntax<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': when I analyzed that here http://sourceforge.net/projects/adempiere/forums/forum/610548/topic/3499390 (2009-12-26)<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': the only difference that can be sustainable for today would be:<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': mercurial pro - Intelligent merging after renames is supported<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': hengsin, do you know if bitbucket pull requests operates samely for git?<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': I'm not sure but the wording they use seems to means it works similarly for both<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': reading this - very fresh opinion -> http://xentac.net/2012/01/19/the-real-difference-between-git-and-mercurial.html<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': ok, done with the readings :-)<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': so hengsin - what would you advice - I would be in pro of creating a git repository and making some tests with hg-git <br>
		+	'''''red1''''': i still get feedback from normal developers not that good with anythig beyond SVN<br>
		+	'''''CIA-2''''': iDempiere: globalqss * 63081814a8b4 r7067 /migration/360lts-release/ (2 files in 2 dirs): Cleaning bad updates (unnecessary and probably overwriting possible customizations) found on 785_744_FR3018857_ImporterInventoryMove.sql migration script<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': yeah, I think it is best to create a git clone for some testing before we decide further<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': red1, it is not really that difficult but many will just comfortable with they already familiar with.<br>
		+	'''''hengsin''''': I means "stay conformtable with what they already familiar with"<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': same story with using Windows (pirated)<br>
		+	'''''buildmaster''''': Project iDempiere build #132: SUCCESS in 18 min: http://jenkins.idempiere.com/job/iDempiere/132/<br>
		+	'''''buildmaster''''': globalqss: Cleaning bad updates (unnecessary and probably overwriting possible customizations) found on 785_744_FR3018857_ImporterInventoryMove.sql migration script<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': /CarlosRuiz using hg-fast-export.sh to create git repository from mercurial<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': ok guys - c u later - I'll publish this full meeting as usual<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': will post a note on the advance on tbayen thread here<br>
		+	'''''CarlosRuiz''''': http://red1.org/adempiere/viewtopic.php?f=32&t=1492<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': ok<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': i will track tbayen once in a while<br>
		+	'''''red1''''': i hear Germans also go to carnivals<br>

IDempiere/FullMeeting20120222 - Revision history

CarlosRuiz: full meeting

CarlosRuiz: proposed agenda